Power BI Direct Query vs Import Mode: Which to Choose?

Introduction

Power BI offers flexible options for connecting to data, including Direct Query, Import Mode, and Composite Models. Choosing the right mode is important to ensure good performance, accurate data, and reports that meet your needs. This guide explains the differences between Direct Query and Import Mode in Power BI, their advantages and limitations, how to switch between them, including steps to convert Direct Query to Import and switch from Direct Query to Import Mode, and answers common questions like, “What is the difference between Import and Direct Query?” Whether you need to manage large datasets, use real-time data, or decide which mode works best for your goals, this guide will help you make the right choice.

Read to until the end to learn why I use import mode in 99% of the cases, don’t miss out!

---

Overview: Power BI Direct Query vs Import

Below is a high-level summary comparing Import Mode and Direct Query in Power BI:

Feature	Import Mode	Direct Query
Refresh Frequency	Scheduled refresh (hourly or daily).	Real-time querying on demand.
Performance	Optimized with cached data for fast results.	Dependent on data source and query complexity.
Data Storage	Data is fully loaded into Power BI’s memory.	Data remains in the source; only schema is stored.
Dataset Size	Up to 1 GB compressed (Power BI Pro).	Unlimited (limited only by the source system).
Row Limit	No limit for in-memory models.	1 million rows per query, per visual.
Security	Fully supports Row-Level Security (RLS) within Power BI.	Relies on source-level RLS; complex to configure.
Unsupported Features	Fully supported.	Limited; e.g., Data View, Calculated Tables, and some DAX functions are unavailable.
Quick Insights	Fully available.	Unavailable in Direct Query mode.
Data Transformations	All transformations supported.	Limited; complex transformations must be performed at the source.
Advanced DAX Functions	Fully supported, including row-level and time intelligence.	Functions like PATH, DATEADD, and complex aggregations may be restricted.
Offline Access	Fully supported.	Not available; always requires a connection to the data source.
Supported Data Sources	All supported.	Limited to Direct Query-compatible sources like SQL Server, Oracle, and SAP HANA.
Performance Dependencies	Independent of the source once data is imported.	Relies heavily on the source’s performance and network speed.
Licensing Requirements	Suitable for Power BI Pro or Premium.	Often used with Power BI Premium for large-scale scenarios.
Use Case	Ideal for static, small-to-medium datasets.	Best for real-time, large, or dynamic datasets.

Key Insights:

1. Row Limit for Direct Query: Queries are limited to 1 million rows per query per visual, which can restrict usability for very large datasets.
2. Unsupported Features:
   • No Data View or Quick Insights.
   • Limited support for calculated columns, calculated tables, and some advanced DAX functions.
3. Dependency on Source: Performance and data availability rely heavily on the speed, efficiency, and optimization of the data source.
4. Source Requirements: Direct Query is only compatible with a select list of data sources. Unsupported sources require Import Mode.

For a complete understanding of the limitations and best practices for Direct Query, refer to the Microsoft documentation on Direct Query limitations.

---

Understanding Data Connectivity Modes in Power BI

When to choose which data connectivity mode? When loading data from a SQL server, Power BI asks you this question:

Import Mode

Import Mode in Power BI is a robust option for storing data in-memory, enabling exceptionally high performance and comprehensive data modeling capabilities. This mode is the preferred choice for working with static datasets that do not require frequent updates or real-time querying. By leveraging cached data, Import Mode ensures fast report interactions and complete access to advanced features such as Data View and complex DAX calculations.

Key Benefits of Import Mode:

• Faster report interactions: Cached data allows for near-instantaneous rendering of visuals.
• Comprehensive modeling capabilities: Full support for Data View, calculated columns, and measures.
• Extensive transformations: Complete flexibility for data preparation and enrichment using Power Query.

However, Import Mode has certain limitations:

• Dataset size constraints: Datasets are limited by the memory capacity of your Power BI environment, typically up to 1 GB per dataset in Power BI Pro.
• Scheduled refreshes: Data updates occur periodically (hourly or daily), which may not meet the needs of scenarios requiring real-time updates.
  

When to Use Import Mode:

• Static or infrequently updated datasets: Ideal for scenarios where data changes are minimal.
• Performance-critical dashboards: Perfect for use cases demanding instantaneous report rendering.
• Advanced modeling needs: Suitable for scenarios requiring complex DAX calculations and in-depth data transformations.

By choosing Import Mode, Power BI users can achieve optimized performance, making it a reliable choice for handling small to medium-sized datasets with high analytical demands.

---

Direct Query Mode

Direct Query Mode in Power BI connects directly to the underlying data source, enabling real-time querying without storing data in Power BI’s memory. This ensures that reports always reflect the most up-to-date data, making it an excellent choice for organizations working with dynamic or large datasets.

Key Advantages of Direct Query Mode:

• Real-time data access: Any changes made to the source data are instantly reflected in reports, ensuring accuracy and timeliness.
• Unlimited dataset size: Since data remains in the source system, there are no constraints on the volume of data queried, unlike Import Mode.
  

Limitations of Direct Query Mode:

While Direct Query Mode offers powerful benefits, it comes with several challenges:

• Performance dependency: The speed of reports relies heavily on the data source and network efficiency. Slow or unoptimized databases can lead to poor user experiences.
• Restricted feature availability: Certain features, such as the Data View in Power BI Desktop and some advanced DAX functions, are unavailable in this mode.
• Slower report interactions: As every interaction triggers a real-time query, latency can occur if the data source is not optimized for high-frequency queries.
  

When to Use Direct Query Mode:

Direct Query Mode is ideal for:

• Large datasets: When datasets are too big to fit within Power BI’s memory limits.
• Real-time scenarios: Use cases requiring up-to-the-minute data updates for decision-making, such as live dashboards.
• Compliance requirements: When organizational policies mandate that data remains on-premises or in the cloud, without replication to Power BI storage.
  

---

Composite Models

Composite Models in Power BI provide a hybrid approach, combining the strengths of Import Mode and Direct Query Mode within a single dataset. This offers unmatched flexibility, enabling organizations to balance performance and data freshness effectively.

Key Benefits of Composite Models:

• Optimized performance: Static tables that do not require frequent updates can utilize Import Mode, ensuring faster report interactions.
• Real-time updates: Dynamic tables configured with Direct Query allow live data to remain updated at all times.
• Enhanced scalability: Perfect for scenarios with hybrid datasets that have varying refresh requirements.
  

Challenges of Composite Models:

• Complex relationships: Managing relationships between Import Mode and Direct Query tables can introduce performance bottlenecks if not designed carefully.
• Query efficiency: Combining tables from both modes in a single query can increase query complexity and impact performance if optimizations are not in place.
  

When to Use Composite Models:

Composite Models are best suited for:

• Hybrid scenarios: When certain data is static but other data requires real-time updates.
• Large datasets: When managing diverse datasets without exceeding memory limits.
• Cost-effective solutions: For projects where licensing constraints, such as refresh limits in Power BI Pro, need to be addressed.

By leveraging Composite Models, Power BI users can harness the real-time power of Direct Query while maintaining the performance advantages of Import Mode, effectively addressing complex reporting requirements.ct Query, Composite Models allow businesses to balance performance and flexibility, meeting complex reporting needs with ease.

---

How Direct Query Works vs Import Mode: A Technical Perspective

In Direct Query mode, Power BI does not store data in its memory. Instead, it sends real-time queries to the connected data source whenever a report is interacted with. Only metadata and schema are stored within Power BI. The data remains at its original location (e.g., SQL Server or Azure SQL Database), ensuring compliance with policies that restrict data storage. This mode allows for up-to-date reports but heavily depends on the performance of the data source and network, which can lead to latency during interactions.

In contrast, Import Mode extracts and loads the dataset directly into Power BI’s in-memory engine. This enables fast report interactions and complete independence from the original data source during usage. However, data in Import Mode requires scheduled refreshes to stay current and is limited by memory constraints (typically up to 1 GB in Power BI Pro). While Direct Query suits real-time needs and large datasets, Import Mode excels in scenarios demanding high performance and extensive modeling capabilities.

---

Supported Data Sources for Direct Query

Direct Query supports a variety of data sources, including traditional databases and modern cloud solutions. Here’s a list of some key supported sources:

Data Source	Direct Query Support
SQL Server	Yes
Azure SQL Database	Yes
Oracle	Yes
SAP HANA	Yes
Google BigQuery	Yes

---

Limitations of Direct Query Mode in Power BI

Direct Query mode offers the significant advantage of real-time data access, but it comes with notable restrictions that users must carefully consider when designing their Power BI models. One major limitation is the inaccessibility of the Data View, which prevents users from visually inspecting datasets in Power BI Desktop. Additionally, some DAX functions—especially those involving row-level operations or calculated tables—are either unsupported or have reduced functionality, restricting advanced analytical capabilities. Complex Power Query transformations and quick insights are also unavailable, necessitating that much of the data preparation happens at the source level.

Moreover, Direct Query introduces performance dependencies on the underlying data source. For every interaction with a visual or slicer, a query is executed in real-time, which can lead to latency if the data source or network isn’t optimized. Security implementations like Row-Level Security (RLS) in Direct Query models can add complexity, and certain modeling features, such as bidirectional relationships, may require careful configuration or be restricted. These limitations highlight the importance of balancing real-time data needs with performance and usability considerations.

Quick Summary: Which functions are not supported in direct query mode?

Unsupported Feature	Details
Data View	Unavailable in Direct Query mode, limiting dataset inspection in Power BI Desktop.
DAX Functions	Functions like PATH and some advanced time intelligence functions (e.g., DATEADD, DATESBETWEEN) may not work as expected. Refer to Microsoft documentation for full details.
Calculated Columns and Tables	Creating calculated columns and tables is not supported; these must be handled at the source.
Quick Insights	Automated insights generation is unavailable in Direct Query models, requiring manual analysis and visualization.
Performance Dependencies	Query performance relies heavily on the data source and network. Poor optimization can lead to significant latency during report interactions.
Merging Queries	Complex merges are not supported and should be optimized in the source database to ensure performance.
Row-Level Security (RLS)	Implementing RLS in Direct Query models can be complex and requires consistent configuration at the source.

Example: You cannot see the data tab when using direct query!

Refresh or Pause Visuals to Improve Development Efficiency

In Power BI Desktop, visuals are refreshed automatically when changes are made, which can significantly slow down the development process, especially when working with large datasets or complex queries. To streamline your workflow, you can pause visual updates and resume them when necessary.

How to Pause Visuals

1. Go to the Optimize tab in Power BI Desktop.
2. Click on the “Pause Visual Queries” button in the ribbon.
3. While visuals are paused, edits can be made to the model or reports without triggering data queries.
   
   

How to Resume Visuals

1. Once you’re ready to see the updated visuals, click on the “Resume Visual Queries” button in the ribbon.
2. Alternatively, use the “Refresh” button on individual visuals to update only specific charts or tables.

Pausing visuals helps reduce unnecessary query execution, improves performance, and ensures a smoother development experience. Make it a habit to pause visuals when making multiple changes to the report or model structure.

---

Switching Between Connectivity Modes

Switching between Import and Direct Query modes is a critical decision that impacts your Power BI model’s performance, features, and data refresh capabilities. The process and considerations differ depending on the direction of the switch.

Power BI Switch from Import to Direct Query

Switching a dataset from Import Mode to Direct Query in Power BI requires careful handling, as simply changing the connection mode in Power Query can lead to errors. Here’s the correct approach:

1. Identify the Dataset:
   • Open the Power BI Desktop file containing the dataset you want to switch.
   • Note the table names and structure for consistency.
2. Delete the Existing Query:
   • Go to Transform Data and delete the query or table currently using Import Mode. Ensure you note any relationships or calculated measures associated with the table.
3. Re-Import the Dataset in Direct Query Mode:
   • Reconnect to the data source by selecting Get Data.
   • During the connection process, choose Direct Query as the storage mode.
   • Use the same table name to maintain relationships and consistency within the model.
4. Validate the Model:
   • After importing the table in Direct Query mode, review relationships and measures in your data model.
   • Certain calculated columns or complex measures that worked in Import Mode may need to be recreated or adjusted to function correctly in Direct Query.
5. Test the Reports:
   • Ensure that all visuals and interactions in your report work as expected.
   • Check the performance of queries, as Direct Query depends on the speed and optimization of the source data.
6. Optimize the Source:
   • Since Direct Query runs queries on the source system, ensure the source database is optimized for performance. Use indexing and query tuning techniques to improve speed.

By following this method, you can switch from Import Mode to Direct Query without running into errors or losing important relationships in your Power BI model. Select the query in Power Query Editor, and choose delete. Then import the same database again, this time as direct query. You may need to re-configure the relationships though, watch out for that!

Switch Between Direct Query and Import Mode in Power BI

Power BI allows you to switch between Direct Query and Import Mode, but this process requires careful consideration as it may have implications for your dataset and report functionality. This step is easier than the previous one, no need to delete any of your queries for that! Here’s how you can switch modes and the key points to remember:

Switching from Direct Query to Import Mode

1. Using the Bottom Right Panel:
   • In Power BI Desktop, navigate to the bottom-right corner where the storage mode (e.g., “Storage Mode: Mixed” or “Direct Query”) is displayed.
   • Click on the storage mode indicator and choose the “Switch All Tables to Import Mode” option. A confirmation dialog will appear outlining the implications of this action.
2. Important Notes:
   • Switching to Import Mode is irreversible. Once you’ve changed the mode to Import, you cannot switch the dataset back to Direct Query.
   • Power BI will refresh all tables and load the data into its in-memory engine, which may take time depending on the data volume.

Once you clicked it, Power BI will ask you if you really want to switch all tables to import mode.

Why Switch to Import Mode?

• You may choose to switch to Import Mode if you need better performance for reports or want to take advantage of advanced features like Data View and complex DAX calculations.
• Import Mode allows for offline access to data, which is ideal for scenarios where real-time data updates are not required.

---

Real-World Scenarios and Best Practices

In a recent project, we managed a sales dataset that initially used Import Mode with 8 refreshes per day, sufficient for historical data. However, as the team required near-real-time insights into open sales, Direct Query became essential. To avoid upgrading to Power BI Premium for 48 refreshes, we adopted a Composite Model. Static tables, such as customer and product data, remained in Import Mode for performance, while the open sales table used Direct Query to maintain live updates. This hybrid solution balanced performance and data freshness without incurring additional licensing costs.

Another example involved a marketing dashboard with historical campaign data stored in Import Mode for analysis and forecasting. Real-time engagement metrics, sourced from an external API, were integrated using Direct Query to provide up-to-the-minute insights. By carefully managing relationships and minimizing query complexity, the team achieved a seamless user experience.

In 99% of my use cases, I rely exclusively on Import Mode because it provides full flexibility, supports advanced data modeling, and ensures optimal performance. I’ve rarely encountered scenarios involving massive datasets that would necessitate Direct Query, making Import Mode the most practical and efficient choice for my projects.

---

FAQ’s Direct Query Power BI

---

Conclusion

Choosing between Direct Query and Import Mode in Power BI is critical for ensuring your reports meet both performance and data freshness requirements. Direct Query mode excels when real-time data updates and compliance with data storage regulations are priorities. On the other hand, Import Mode is ideal for scenarios requiring high performance, offline access, and advanced modeling features like Data View and complex DAX calculations.

For more complex scenarios, Composite Models provide the flexibility to combine the strengths of both modes, offering the best balance between real-time data and optimized performance. However, understanding the limitations of each mode, such as unsupported features in Direct Query or memory constraints in Import Mode, is essential for designing efficient and scalable Power BI solutions.

By carefully evaluating your dataset size, data refresh needs, and compliance requirements, you can select the right mode to create powerful, responsive, and reliable Power BI reports. With these considerations in mind, Power BI empowers businesses to transform their data into actionable insights, whether through Direct Query, Import Mode, or a combination of both.

Thanks for reading to this point. I know this topic was not easy to grasp! If you are new to Power BI and want to know how long it takes to master it, read my next article! “How long does it take to learn Power BI”